Aha Moments: More on Notice and Note

A Place for Teachers to Write, Reflect and Grow

A Place for Teachers to Write, Reflect and Grow

Aha moments come to me in short bursts and little snippets. Usually they come to me when the technology is away and the distractions of the world are minimal. I’ve often thought I could take a dry erase board in the shower to capture the aha moments that come to me then. Sometimes while I’m driving, I get ideas for lessons or have epiphanies that have gone unrealized in the past.

Late this afternoon while driving home after a long day at school,  I was thinking about my intro lesson for the signpost  of aha moments. And, yes, I had an aha moment about aha moments. The sample lesson included an aha moment that was neither positive nor prolific.  Crash’s aha moment comes to him as he realizes that he must block the passage of Penn Webb, the scrawny kid next door. As a reader who finds an aha moment,  you should ask, “How might this change things?” Well, as you would expect Crash’s aha moment is followed by his bullying and taunting of Penn Webb. Eventually, though as in most YA lit, his aha moments change and develop and lead to growth and insight.

In early January, I was looking through some resources about close reading, and suddenly I realized that I wasn’t “getting” it. I definitely couldn’t close read in the style of Coleman, nor could I  get into the Prentice Hall book that had been given to me about Close Reading.  Annotating the text seemed difficult for my 6th graders, and I could tell I needed to find something that would work for me and for my students. After a bit of Googling, I found myself on YouTube listening to Kylene Beers and Bob Probtst talk about close reading in a way that made sense in such a powerful way that I immediately bought their book Notice and Note,  read the book and began implementing their close reading strategies.

In a little less than a month, I realize (yes, another a-ha moment) that I have put a lot on my plate as a literary and literacy leader (as school ela department chair and as a participant in KMWP’s Advanced Leadership Institute).  For the remainder of this school year, I will be trying out the close reading strategies in my class, presenting the strategies at a literacy conference, and helping other ela teachers in my grade level teach these strategies. During the first half of next year, I plan to take these strategies school wide in ela. Then, we will work on close reading strategies for non-fiction in ela (I hope to find out soon what those non-fiction signposts will be), and finally my hope is to teach these strategies so well in ELA that all content areas will embrace and encourage the students to use these strategies.

I have been working on developing objectives that build upon one another with action steps along the way that will help bring this project to fruition. Here I am a visionary and big picture kind of girl trying to bring to fruition school wide teaching practices that cultivate close reading. SCARY!

See the anchor chart below with the anchor question for an aha moment, “How might this change things?”

Initially, I may crash like Crash. I may struggle in working through ways to develop close reading skills in students that meet the demands of the Common Core and value the students as thinkers, learners, and humans. Bringing my plan to fruition school wide may be a struggle, even with the support I have of teachers in my department as well as my administrative team. My aha moment  is that working through the struggles is what it’s all about. In the end, though, I truly believe by making these strategies second nature and multi-disciplinary, I  will have helped create students who are attentive, observant, reflective, and questioning readers. That is a life lesson that I can’t afford to not teach students. 

Aha Moment


6 thoughts on “Aha Moments: More on Notice and Note

  1. Ramona

    I continue to be amazed by your posts about Notice and Note. My favorite part of this one is your vision for what these strategies will do for students – “I will have helped create students who are attentive, observant, reflective, and questioning readers.” I want to join you in this journey. Please continue to share your thinking with us.


  2. How appropriate to have an Aha discovery as you are discussing and thinking about the Aha’s from Beers and Probst. I’ve been doing a lot of researching on close reading too and thinking how does this look in K-2. It’s not going to be easy, but it is work that teachers need to explore.


  3. Maya, I have so many professional books I want to read, or finish, but you have really intrigued me with these posts about notice & note, & this above sounds very good! You’ve taken on a lot, as you say, so congratulations for not shying away from a big challenge! Thank you-I’m going to try some of the info in some book groups I’m doing.


  4. Thanks. I’m thinking if I’m going to make this happen school wide, I need to try the strategies, reflect, and be ready to support others. The quote you like is something Bob Probst said in one of his Heinemann videos–maybe I should have quoted him.


  5. Elsie, I’ll keep my eyes peeled for resources for K-2. I think some of the signposts exist in picture books, too. Another thought I like in N and N is that the rigor isn’t all about the level of the text it is about what they do with the text. I know my kindergarten child can notice and note quite a bit when we’re reading.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s